I bought these in the dark brown for my husband. I sized down to a 10.5 (he usually wears an 11) and they fit perfectly. They seem like a good quality shoe. He likes them a lot!
My husband has only had a chance to wear these around the house but he says they are pretty comfortable. He doesn’t plan on walking miles in them so it works. Right away you can see crease marks from his steps which some people may not like but I think it gives them that “worn in” look. They do scratch easily, however, which may or may not be prevented with a protective spray for leather. Will have to try it.
These boots felt and looked great! They are clearly of high quality, and have the classic look that I wanted. However, I do feel that they ran a bit larger than expected. I was still able to wear them, but I'd recommend choosing a .5 size under what you normally get.