This is a perfect light scent. I usually rotate between this #4 as well as #3. Love both. Nice and light and both smell great. Continue to love Trish McEvoy!
Overall rating
5/ 5
chloesmimi
fromIowa
Age:55-59
Soft and feminine scent
PostedApril 19, 2015
Prosfeminine, light, floral, fresh, delicate
This is my second purchase and I love this scent! It is more gardenia than musk which I like. I'm not sure why another reviewer said it smelled like alcohol and didn't stay. That is not my experience at all. My first bottle just had the 4 Gardenia on it and didn't say Gardenia Musk, so I was hoping this was the same scent and it is. Some flower scented perfumes don't smell like the real flower but this one does. Not sure if they also have a companion body lotion but I would love that for some scent layering. I like a delicate scent that isn't overpowering. My young granddaughter always tells me I smell good when I wear this!
I've always worn Amazing Grace. Since it came out. But since they sold it to Coty & made it mostly alcohol, I've not purchased it again. I've been looking for a substitute...and I think this is it. It has Gardenia & musk like Amazing Grace did.....I think I'll be sticking w/this. Hope McEvoy doesn't decide to discontinue it or sell it off. The #9 is all over the place, even HSN, but I don't see much of the #4. Which isn't as heavy & in your face like the #9.
1 of 2 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
1/ 5
Glowgirl1970
fromAtlanta, GA
Gardenia Musk
PostedApril 26, 2013
The fragrance does not smell like gardenia or musk for that matter. It smells like pure rubbing alcohol when you spray it. Then it quickly evaporates and smells like nothing at all. I had such high hopes for this based on the rave reviews, but I cannot see or smell what all the hype is about.
