It flaked off after a few hours of being applied. This product does take a little while to dry, so it is best to avoid if you are in a hurry. I tried to create a smooth line but it can be difficult, however, it good for creating a wing.
I am always in search of the perfect stay-put liner. This one holds up pretty well. The tip is good, I would have preferred the applicator a little longer for a tighter and skinnier line. Great black color, although the color pay-off is difficult to manage, since the applicator tip is so small and doesn't hold too much product at once.
