I've been using this eyeliner for years, but normally use the color Espresso Ink. This time I decided to try the Sepia Ink. I switched colors because I felt like the Espresso Ink was a bit too dark/harsh. I have fair skin and blue eyes. The Sepia Ink color is not as dark, and I can build the color. The reason this got four stars is for some reason it doesn't stay on as well when I sweat.
This eye liner is crazy good. I stopped using pencils a few years ago once I discovered these gel pots. They are so long lasting, 12 hours later my eye liner still looks perfect. Very easy to apply with an eyeliner brush. Glides on smoothly and you can do a thin line or a thicker one. Also easy to give a little wing with these. The colors are saturated and beautiful. I have black, navy blue, Ivy (gorgeous green) and just got the espresso. Never any tugging on your eyes with these. Holy grail product.
I love Bobbi Brown products. However, I wish you didn't have to send three separate packages - such a waste for small items. Can't you just gather all items and send them in one package?