Purchased this in Espresso and Ivy Shimmer. Both are great colors. Easy to apply with the BB Ultra Precise Eyeliner brush. Stays put. Not too harsh looking.
It may not be 100% smudge proof but way better than the high end liquid eyeliners. The BB applicator is worth every penny for more control on how ligh or heavy you want to line your eyes w/ better control. Plus this little jar will last 3 times longer than the liquid liners in the thin pens.