I’ve been using this eyeliner for years, and it’s amazing. Goes on clean and easy. Stays on all day without smearing. I have extremely sensitive skin, especially around my eyes, and I’ve never had any issues with this
Well….what’s all the hype about this eyeliner??? It smears and doesn’t last. I do not have oily eyelids, I use a waterproof primer on my eyelids before I put any eye makeup on. The only eyeliner that will not smudge and smear is a waterproof liquid eyeliner. In fact the Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof does not budge and it’s a lot cheaper. The BB gel glides on easy but sorry….it doesn’t stay put whatsoever. It fades by the end of the day. Again, I don’t have oily skin or eyelids. So oily eyelids beware. I’m a makeup artist and have worked with many different eyeliners, I like the Maybelline one the best. Won’t be buying BB eyeliner again. It’s too expensive not to stay put perfectly all day like an eyeliner should. I even bought the brush that goes with it. Not impressed by this liner, sending back.
I've purchased the Chocolate Shimmer Ink a couple of times because I remember fondly the days when MAC had several colors of their Fluidline and not just black or brown. However, the container is smaller and it dries out way fast- and then just becomes an awful mess when you try to grab it out of the pot. I'd say it stays creamy for about 3 months and anyone who uses this sort of product conservatively knows these products last 3 times that long usually.The last time I purchased this I even made a comment to the salesperson and she says to actually close it immediately, so they know it's an issue.
