This is a great tube mascara that washes away with just warm water but stays put until then. There is no flaking or smudging and gone are the raccoon eyes! The only negative is that it dries out quickly so you can’t buy until you’re ready to use.
This is the best mascara I have ever used. It truly does not smudge, AT ALL! I have tried many mascaras from drug stores to dept store brands over many years. This is the only one that stays on all day and doesn't leave raccoon eyes. I am so glad my girlfriend told me about it 3 years. I switched and now highly recommend it to others.