Maybe I'm just used to wearing bad eyeliner... but this eyeliner is awesome! It doesn't smear or transfer onto my upper lid even after a sweaty workout!
I have been using Clinique products for years. The Quickliner for Eyes Eyeliner Pencil is a must-have in my opinion. The color goes on easily and no sharpener is needed. I always use the New Black shade which is dark, but soft at the same time.
I ordered this pencil in two different colors and upon first use I opened the length of the "lead" to see how much product was in it; that seemed fine until I tried to retract the lead and it would not go back into the pencil. I have never encountered this before so I tried the other one since I wanted to see if maybe it was defective .. no difference. I tried to very gently persuade the lead back into the pencil but it broke off. Now it's totally useless. I've never seen a pencil that would not turn in the cylinder and retract. I have returned them both. I'm very disappointed since I thought the color was probably perfect for me.
