I have used this Clinque eyeliner for years! It goes on so smoothly and doesn't pull on the eyelid. Some eyeliners dry out or pull. This does not! It is long wearing and even lasts during a workout!
Subpar Clinique product--or perhaps I got a bad batch? The product itself is crumbly and often breaks or flakes off even when a tiny length is exposed. Also, there is too much plastic packaging in relation to the small amount of product. I've been using Clinique for 30 years but wouldn't recommend this or buy it again.
