I love the Clinique lip liners because unlike other brands I've used, it will stay put throughout the entire day. Even when I drink water. Something about the texture is awesome. It isn't super creamy to where it'll easily wipe off. 10/10 recommend.
The product is a bit disappointing. I like the automatic pencill, but it seems a little dry, not a good replacement for discontinued La Prairie pencil, but a far lower price. Will not purchase agsin
I use Baby buff, which is the most natural lipliner color I've found so far. I'm blonde and fair, so this shade gives my lips just enough definition without looking harsh or too dark. I usually just fill in the lips with it as well. It goes on easily and stays on. Love it!