I have to say at beginning I didn’t like it and wanted to return. But after I saw all these good reviews, I decided to give a try. It is definitely not easy for first time users. I didn’t realize you need to wet the brush first then mix with the powder. I tend to get too much water, so the first few lines are very watery and light. This product takes some practice to get it right. But now I like it. The brush is soft and doesn’t hurt my eyelids like some eyeliner pen. The only complaint I have is that the color is not black black. I would say dark grey. I like real black more.
I have been using this eyeliner for many years. I am hyper-sensitive to many products which can cause swelling of my eyelids or just irritation and this Clinique eyeliner does not cause a reaction. It is also very durable, lasting throughout the day. I couldn't be happier with this product.
This product is an oldie but goody — been using it a long time. The brush makes a perfect line, unlike most I’ve tried. It’s water proof and smudge free — a must with my oily skin. Love it!