I love this powder!! I use it every single day to set my make up and have been for around 4+ years now. It does not make my makeup look cakey and it helps with my oil. I don't know how it compares to other setting powders as I've only used this one and haven't wanted to try others.
Best powder ever. Love the translucent, as I don't want a colored powder over my foundation. This powder works wonders, and like all Clinique products, does it without fragrances, etc.
I've been using using this powder about 30 years. I've tried others, but this one is the best. Goes on smoothly, and never cakes. And doesn't irritate my sensitive skin.