Love the color, it is so nice to have something that is not black or so brown it is almost black. Goes on well with minimal clumping. Volume and length is great too.
There was a recall on YSL Baby Doll mascara, which I usually buy, so they recommended this one. No complaints. I think it provides more thickening than Baby Doll. The brush separates lashes really well. Think Baby Doll is a more subtle look than Volume Effet, which is more my style, but I'm really happy with this one too.