Used to be better. The last three or four purchases have been clumpy upon opening. That is unusual for this brand. I’ve had to toss it in a month vs the usual 3-ish. Maybe they changed the formula again.
This is a great product! It was recommended by a friend because she knows I hate having "black eyes" after all day use. This comes off so easily in this shower and when washing. Literally, just slips off.