I love Trish McEvoy makeup - and I did like the formula but wish it had a bigger brush on the wand - I definitely think my $10 drugstore mascara is a better buy for the money.
I bought this after a reality star whose reviews I trust, posted that she loved it and has used it for years. It is a completely fine mascara but I feel like other brands make my lashes fuller. This mascara goes on well and does not smudge easily but it is pretty difficult to remove, and it can make your lashes clumpy. I think someone that wears very minimal makeup might prefer this mascara.