I love this pencil. It seems like the "drier" my eyelid the better the application, so I have had more success putting this on first then working my other makeup around it. Then it is really "black" and really "waterproof". I have this in Engraved.
MAC Powerpoint is the best eye pencil in the market. It doesn't smear or smudge and stays on all day. And it doesn't hurt that Nordstrom provides the best customer service.