This pencil stays on pretty well during the day. I really like the Graphite color; I tried the Ambre but ended up returning because I wanted more definition. The Noir would be way better for me.
I have this pencil in both the black and the marine colors and I really enjoy them. The only thing is the Marine color is very dark, more of a blue black/dark navy but I'll keep it anyway. It goes on smooth and can do a great cat eye. I love the formula, it feels very luxurious.
Great product. The color is perfect with intense pigment, is long wearing and waterproof. I've ordered this eyeliner several times from Nordstrom and I just love it! The shipping is fast and every product I order never disappoints me.