This lip color is as good as everyone says. Goes on beautifully. Stays on all evening (though I did have to reapply after dinner.) Cruella is the perfect red too!
I love this pencil. It stays on your lips and has a lovely, velvety matte look. I usually put a lip gloss or lipstick with a little sheen to bump it up a little.
Loved the color ordered and smooth consistency when applying but just didn't stay that well. I also experienced some feathering. The other complain was it was not retractable which I always feels wastes some of the pencil, no matter how carefully you may sharpen it.