Great price and great shoes. This is my 8th pair of Allen Edmonds, and 2nd pair of the Park Avenue. I think that is enough for you to make the decision.
This is my second pair. My first I wore as an everyday shoe and wore through the sole in less than 2 years when I mostly sit at a desk and walk on carpet. They break in nicely and maintain a great shine. Would be a 4 or 5 star had they not worn so quickly...