I agree with other reviewers that the quality of the samples are much better. I bought it because I liked the samples given free by nordstrom. I dont use waterproof make up so it cleans my make up.
I initially received a small sample of this and it worked great to remove MAC eye shadow, Urban Decay liquid liner, and CK One Mascara. I have since changed mascara to Urban Decay Perversion and it it terrible at getting it off! So I guess it works on some types of eye make up. I suppose the Perversion mascara is long-lasting/waterproof. Bottom line, I recommend getting a sample to make sure it works with the type of eye makeup you use.