Love the Cassis color, a deep purple tone, better than just black, dark color. Waterproof but not smudge proof. Tip tends to break when near the end of the product.
Purple chocolate is a beautiful color, HOWEVER, it has a lot of gold glitter in it! Once I saw that I used eye makeup remover to remove it and have washed my eyes twice with my aloe vera face soap. As I was putting on eyeline this morning (rest assured it was not this one!) I noticed I STILL have glitter around my eyes! I'm not sure why it's not mentioned in the description but as one who hates glitter, I returned it post haste!
I love this eyeliner, especially the cassis color. It's great for brown eyes. It's a subtle eggplant color. The pen itself works well, it glides on nicely without making too thick of a line. It's not very easy to sharpen however but its not necessary.
