This is my favorite mascara of all time! I have naturally straight lashes, and after I curl them, this holds the curl all day. It doesn't clump, and it stays on all day. I have tried so many other brands, and none has ever come close to this one.
Sadly, not smudge proof. This mascara looked so beautiful and lengthening and so natural, but it ended up all over my eyes. It's really too bad because I've never used a mascara that wasn't thick and clumpy and obvious. No clumps here.