I love these boots, but if you're short they will look more like waiters on you than boots. I'm 5'7" and they come directly to my kneecap. I have muscular calves and they did fit, so that's good. I love the color of the grey that I got, and I even like the box it came in. These rain boots are well made too!
Bought in both black and the green color option. The green was horrible and has been returned, I thought it would be a nice olive color but was mistaken. I would say they the best color options would be grey or black. They go with everything. I am an 8.5 and bought the 8.