This is the only mascara that I will buy now. It isn't clumpy and seems to separate lashes well and go on evenly. It stays put all day and even throughout a very sweaty workout! Then easily comes off in the shower with warm water.
I've tried other mascaras, but I always go back to this one. No smudging. Lasts all day, and then washes off with warm water. Don't try to use makeup remover!