607 out of 663(92%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
4/ 5
Mel
fromCalgary, AB
Great mascara
PostedFebruary 19, 2020
Great mascara. Doesn't flake or smudge and comes off easy. Only one complaint - the size, very small.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
3/ 5
Margie
fromLawton OK
It's Tough But.....
PostedFebruary 12, 2020
Well, this mascara is very tough and holds up for a very long time and even seems to be very resistant to water. However, in my opinion, I didn't find it "easy" to remove. It is very difficult to remove- even with various kinds of eye makeup remover and even baby oil. Unlike waterproof mascara, this product "flakes" and comes off in fragments and usually ends up with a lot of "floaters" in the eyeball. I had to really "pull/tug" at my eye lashes to get the product off which ended up pulling out a few eye lashes. It's definitely double wear. And it stays put, and could probably even be slept in overnight but I believe the waterproof mascara is better for me rather than the double wear just because of the removal process.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
Thank you so much for sharing your experience with us, Margie, and we greatly appreciate the time you took to do so. We want you to love your mascara and we recommend removing this with Take It Away Gentle Eye & Lip LongWear Makeup Remover. This removes long-wearing shadows and liners, as well as waterproof mascara and is gentle removal for around your eyes! Learn more about it here: https://estee.cm/TIAEyeLip. We also invite you to connect with a Beauty Advisor here: https://estee.cm/ChatUS, for more tips and tricks. They are happy to assist!
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
4/ 5
Tg
fromShropshire
No panda eyes
PostedFebruary 8, 2020
After trying lots of mascara but always ending with black smudges under my eyes throughout the day like a panda, i thought i would try this. I was not disappointed as it doesnt smudge or come off throughout the day and no panda eyes. My only grumble is the soft brush wand and i wish it was a bit more rigid as can clog up after a few weeks. However as long as you buy new ones at this point its great
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
5/ 5
Leah
fromRiver Forest, IL
Favorite Mascara!
PostedFebruary 8, 2020
This is the best mascara I've used, and I've tried a lot of them. It doesn't flake off like other mascaras, and it is very natural looking (not clumpy). If you use a mascara primer before applying it, you can get the look of lash extensions and still not have to worry about smudges and raccoon eyes.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
