607 out of 663(92%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
3/ 5
NurU
fromDenver, CO, USA
Lies- It Smudges
PostedMay 8, 2017
I love Estee Lauder foundations to death so I was rather thrilled to try this supposedly zero-smudge mascara. The packaging is sleek and classy, hence the three stars. However, after 2 hours of application, I found black rings under my eyes. The mascara definitely transferred to under my eyes. Bummer since I purchased this online from the website and threw away the return receipt since I was so convinced I would love it.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
We're troubled to hear this didn't work out for you! Give us a call at 1-877-311-3883 and we'll help you with an exchange.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
4/ 5
JJH74
fromBradenton, FL
Very good mascara
PostedMay 2, 2017
I have very sensitive eyes. Many brands of make-up make my eyes turn red and tear up. This mascara does not. It offers really nice lash extension, does not clump, and is long lasting.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
1/ 5
goldengem1989
fromDetroit, MI, USA
Gets clumpy after a week
PostedApril 28, 2017
I ordered this because I needed new mascara. After a week the mascara started to build up against the opening of the bottle. There is way too much product put in the bottle to the point where it clumps and turns dry all over the opening of the bottle. I threw it away after a week.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
Thanks for letting us know how you feel. We appreciate your feedback and will forward appropriately.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
3/ 5
plus2
fromUSA
Creates length and volume
PostedApril 24, 2017
Great results using this mascara, I find that it adds lots of volume and length to my lashes (which are so bare to begin with). The only downside is that I have to layer quite a bit, and sometimes there is smudging. But overall, I find that this is great. The price is a bit higher compared o other mascaras though.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
Thanks for sharing! You may wish to try Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara instead. The fiber rich formula and over-sized brush magnifies and multiplies the look of lashes and even fills in the sparsest lashes for a full fan effect. Let us know what you think!
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
