607 out of 663(92%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
5/ 5
happykt1116
fromPortland, OR, USA
Best Mascara Ever
PostedApril 9, 2017
Prosanyone
I used to have a mascara I loved from another brand, but they changed and no longer worked for me. I work 13 hours as a RN. I was having a hard time finding a mascara that wouldn't run on my face. Another co-worker suggested that I try this mascara. This mascara is amazing. Doesn't run, doesn't flake. My lashes feel healthy. Mascara is really this biggest focus of my routine and I'm so pleased that I have something that really make my eyes pop again.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
5/ 5
R8thx
fromEssex
Zero smudge
PostedApril 7, 2017
LOVE this mascara, does exactly what is says, even after going to the gym! Wouldn't use anything else.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
2/ 5
Jessicaanneli
fromSterling Heights, MI, USA
Just ok
PostedApril 4, 2017
I had high hopes for this mascara but it left me disappointed. It doesn't add much volume and it made my lashes feel and look crusty and dry. Adding a second layer made things even worse. It dries very fast, so it tends to clump up quickly giving you an unflattering look. I wanted to try something new and this had such rave reviews but I won't be buying this again.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
So sorry to hear this! One layer is definitely all that you need. If you like to build your lashes for added drama, try Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara instead.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
Overall rating
1/ 5
Yellow7
fromTexas, USA
Only if you have natural curly eyelashes
PostedApril 2, 2017
Prosnot sure
I do not have natural curly eyelashes, so I always have to use the eyelash curler before applying any mascara so that my eyelashes can look nice. I always get compliments about my eyelashes, by the way. But with this mascara, I curled my eyelashes, as usual, and then applied it, but they ended up looking horrible. After applying this one, my eyelashes got straight again. They looked stiff and ended up pointing downward. I threw it away. I had to remove it, and do my eyelashes all over again with my usual Cover Girl waterproof one that always leaves my eyelashes looking pretty all day long without having to re-touch.
Response from esteelauder.comBy esteelauderpwr, esteelauderpwr, October 3, 2025
We're sorry to hear it's not everything you had hoped for! We'd love to chat with you further and explore why this may be happening. Click on Live Chat icon (bottom left of the page) for instant advice.
Written by a customer while visiting esteelauder.com
