41 out of 77(53%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
1/ 5
gobears13
PostedAugust 4, 2011
It dries out so fast. Didn't even last me a month.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
5/ 5
mliu
fromsouthern california
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:brown
Age:20-24
Line It Like You Mean It
PostedAugust 3, 2011
Proslong-lasting
I'm a huge fan of this liquid liner. I've used all sorts from Nars, Chanel, Dior, and even picks from the drug stores. MAC's penultimate is definitely the one for me.
Since the liner is like a pen it's easy to hold in my hand so that I can make a precise line in my eyelid. My usual eye look is a thick "cat-eye" look to make my eyes look bigger. The pen distributes a good amount of liquid but not too much to the point where you'll have worry about it being runny. The color is solid black, and to ensure that the color doesn't fade throughout the day I use the MAC paint pot (in Painterly for me) on my eyelids before, which goes on creamy and lets the liner show the bold black color you want.
I've been using this pen liner for over 3 years now and still love it. Since I use this pen daily (I will always line my eyes even if I don't wear any other makeup) it lasts around 3-4 months which is more than I could ask for.
Picture is of my eye after 10 hours of wear. It also lasts through my post-work yoga class!
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
1/ 5
AKFashionista
fromAlaska
Skin Type:normal
Eye Color:brown
Age:25-29
Surprise Disappoinment
PostedMay 13, 2011
Prosdries out
I ADORE most MAC products--Unfortunately, I had the worst experience with this liner. The first eyeliner dried out after only one use--i wanted to give MAC the benefit of the doubt, so i chalked it up as a fluke and purchased another penultimate liner. The second liner dried out after two days...I double checked that i securely replaced the lid after each use...Don't waste your money on this liner, it will dry out on you!
2 of 2 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
5/ 5
missfancy
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:brown
Age:25-29
PostedApril 12, 2011
Proseasy to blend, long-lasting
Best liquid eyeliner!! I love how dark the midnight black is and how precise the tip of the pen which allows you to not miss any areas and corners of your eyelids. I love it!! I've inspired many people at work and anywhere to get it bc I always get complemented on my beautiful eyes which is in thanks due to do this pen.
