64 out of 68(94%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
5/ 5
ardysa
fromNew Jersey
Skin Type:normal
Skin Tone:light
Eye Color:green
Age:45-49
Just bought three
PostedDecember 14, 2012
Proseasy to blend, long-lasting
These are the best eyeliners I've found. The color goes on smoothly and the smudging end of the pencil softens the line as much as you want. The color stays put. I really like the bronze color and the plum.
Graphite is a good neutral color choice in this pencil for something less bold than black but still significant for defining lash line. (I only use liner on upper lashes.)
Also, the texture of this is good for gliding on easily. No tugging on lids to get the job done.
Also, after a few seconds of "set time", this becomes virtually non smudge-able so it stays put.
Last, the pencil contains just the smallest amount of irridescence. I didn't notice this until after I purchased it and normally that would have been a "no sale" item for me as my sensitive skin is normally irritated by anything the least bit "sparkle". But in the case of this pencil, no irritation at all for my sensitve eye lids.
Now the not so good things:
This pencil is of a design and texture that needs frequent sharpening to make it most easily usable. However, it does not come with a sharpener. These Estee pencils should come with a sharpener designed to fit their shape and texture.
Bottom line:
This liner does not stay on any longer than some others I've used in both Estee sister companies of Bobbi Brown and Clinique. For long wear Bobbi Brown's pencil is better, if more "tug prone" to apply. For ease of application, with no sharpener needed, Clinique's Quickliner is just as good. This Estee pencil was a fun experiment, but not a product for which I'd make a repeat purchase.
6 of 6 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
5/ 5
Beebdobop
best eyliner ever!
PostedOctober 31, 2011
Proseasy to blend, smudgable, long-lasting, non irritating, no film in eyes, blends very well, nice color
I work outside in the weather even when it's pouring down rain so I wear waterproof eyeliner. It's very hard to find a good eyeliner that lasts & doesn't wash off or smear and this liner is the absolute best I've ever used. I will never buy another brand again!
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
5/ 5
Abbey130
fromOrange County, CA
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:brown
Age:30-34
Awesome!
PostedOctober 24, 2011
Proseasy to blend, long-lasting, stay in place
After years of searching I finally found this wonderful smudge-free eyeliner! It lasts long & the colors are beautiful.
