Hello there! We deeply appreciate your long-standing loyalty to Kiehl's and are truly saddened to hear of your disappointment regarding the discontinuation of our Original Musk Oil. We understand this decision has been frustrating, especially given its significance to you and other loyal customers. We want to sincerely apologize for any perception of manipulation with the "Notify Me" feature. Our intention was to offer a way for interested customers to receive updates if the product became available again. However, we recognize how this can be misinterpreted in the context of a discontinued product and will address this on our website. The decision to discontinue a product is never taken lightly and is based on a number of complex factors, including ingredient availability, regulatory changes, and evolving customer preferences. We understand that this doesn't lessen the disappointment for those who loved the Original Musk Oil. While we can't bring back this specific fragrance, we are committed to offering a wide range of high-quality skincare and fragrance options. We invite you to explore our other collections and perhaps discover new Kiehl's favorites. Our customer service team is also available to help you find alternative scents that might resonate with you. We value your feedback immensely and are always striving to improve. We hope, despite this experience, you'll reconsider your decision in the future.