Glides on easily but no staying power. Slides off/barely visible within an hour of application. Have recently made the switch to using only clean beauty, skin and bath products. There are very few “clean” eyeliners out there (so far) and this is the only one I’ve found that is brown instead of a harsh black. Hopefully another clean cosmetics line will eventually create a long-wear eyeliner in a few more shades as well.... until then I’ll be trying this with the Ilia natural brightening eye primer (not yet available at Nordstrom) and hoping that this eye liner’s wear longevity improves.
I love this pencil. I was worried it would smudge and wear off. It glides on easily and stays put the whole day. It doesn't smudge or wear off. It doesn't say 'waterproof' but my eyes water a lot and this doesn't come off until you take it off. I highly recommend!
