I have been using the Bobbi Brown eye brown pencil for 10 years. The reason that I like it is that it is more like an eye shadow than a pencil. It goes on smoothly and is able to be wiped off with a Q-tip if I don't get the line of the eyebrow exactly right. The color, grey, is exactly the color of my dark brown eyebrows. I like it also because it is a powder and doesn't have the stickiness of a crayon Kohl pencil. I always get compliments on my eyes and no one has ever thought I use an eyebrow pencil. Also, the price is right! I have recommended this pencil to many of my friends!
I have scant eyebrows and found powder worked best for me until I tried this. Wow, easy to use, looks very natural and if I make a mistake, I have a brush that corrects it. Cannot recommend this enough. Very happy with it.
I've tried a few different eyebrow pencils, and this one is my favorite! Other pencils I've used are too creamy/waxy and don't glide well on my brows, but this pencil has a nice consistency. I don't have to apply a lot or press down hard to get good coverage. It's great for filling in sparse areas without making my brows look like they have been drawn on. I've been using this brow pencil for the last few years, and even though it's a bit pricey, I will keep buying it!
Finally found THE brow pencil. Very richly pigmented so you only have to apply it lightly. I have tried a lot of different brands of brow pencils; even tried gel brow liners. This is by far the best.