I was looking for an under eye corrector to replace my Bobbi Brown tinted eye brightener that was discontinued and re-packaged. I was skeptical at first since the counter manager tested out the mauve/rose colour. Of course I thought how on earth would that conceal anything if it's red?! When she used it in conjection with LM secret concealer and LM Secret Brightening Powder I really noticed a difference. It does take some time to get used to from what I used to use, but so far I am pleased with the results and with the LM line. A little goes a long way as well.