OMG these boots are AMAZING!!! I randomly tried them on at a store today and couldn't walk away without them. I sometimes struggle with boots fitting my calves; these fit perfectly with jeans tucked in and I even have a little room. The fact that they are waterproof is just an added benefit to how nice they look and how wonderful they feel on!! I wish Nordstrom sold them in brown too because those would've come home with me too!!!
This is a great boot. They are very comfortable and look good on. The style is classic. The wide calf is wide enough for my wide calves. They are well constructed to boot (pun intended; but in all seriousness, if you have wide calves, this boot will work well and you will have years of wear).
I love these boots, though it took me ordering 2 times to get the right size. They run kind of narrow in the wide width but the length is true to size. I have an extra large calf (18 1/2) and these boots stretched to fit my calf. I did wear them for a few hours a day around the house to get the goring to stretch enough to work. They fit perfectly now and I have no regrets about buying them. Hoping they continue to wear well as the rainy weather is upon us.