color says intense charcoal; there's nothing intense about it, and it's more metallic silver looking than charcoal. Color is not intense pigment at all and does not cover. It's more of a dark wash. returned it to the store. the sample of the black one was worn down to nothing but I took a fresh one. When I tried it at home it was NOT a solid black, again more of a wash. it's going back and I'll have to start with a different brand. They should definitely remove the word "intense" from the name of it
I should have tried earlier. It did not smear almost for 7 hours,I love the softness of the pencil,no tugging.I have tried at least 8 different brand,so far Clinique is the best.
The chocolate color is very pretty eyeliner glides on smooth, I like the make up forever pencil like this that has a sharpner in the lid, this one gets blunt and I have to use a eyeliner brush to perfect the line on my eyes.
