32 out of 59(54%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
1/ 5
Smking6
Age:30-34
Poorly made
PostedJuly 19, 2016
This package design is poor. Had difficulty opening the eyeliner without the powder spilling. After a few days I pulled it out of my makeup organizer and the one end had broken making it impossible to use. Ended up throwing it out. Very dissatisfied
I have a lot of Jane Iredale eye products and generally love them. This was a fail for me, mainly because its so hard to get the product out. The color is beautiful.
Overall rating
1/ 5
0113mom
fromIllinois
Age:45-49
Skin Type:dry
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:hazel
Will return this product
PostedFebruary 9, 2015
Prosdoesn't work
Generally like her products but will return this product. It is supposed to be an eyeliner but is actually a eye shadow. It would be acceptable if the eye shadow worked well but it is impossible to get a dark line around the eye.
I purchased this eyeliner in purple. The color is pretty in the tube but when applied is not as purply as I would expect. It is also difficult to get a very fine line drawn and I end up with a thicker line above my lashes (this doesn't really bother me, though). I do like the highlighter end and the shimmer this creates.
