This is a new tonic for me. I used Clinique for many years with non alcohol formula. It went away so I switched companies. Then recently I have come back to Clinique's new all skins non alcoholic formula. There is something like witch hazel in it. I am not sure how my skin is reacting to that at the moment. Otherwise I would rate this tonic a 5.
I love trying new products and try different timers frequently but I always seem to come back to this old standby. It exfoliates and removes dead skin and stings in the best way haha. I really feel like my skin is smoother and brighter with this in my routine.