I love this stuff - never sticky, doesn't leave a weird lip stain, always well moisturized. It's technically a lipstick, but feels and acts like a gloss. I only deduct one star because of the phallic name. Really, Clinique?!
I have always liked the quality associated with Clinique products, however, this one falls short. It makes me lips dry so I have to reapply it constantly and the color isn't that great. It's not the true nude I was looking for.
I've been on the hunt for a great nude lip color that doesn't cake into my lips, and finally found Chubby Stick in Heaping Hazelnut. It goes on smoothly and is glossy but not too shiny. The perfect shade for a casual / light beige that isn't overwhelming but still pretty. It goes on sheer, and does need to be re-applied throughout the day, but that doesn't really bother me.