30 out of 32(94%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
5/ 5
runs small
runs large
runs narrow
runs wide
LSBean
Age:25-29
so comfortable & stylish
PostedJune 26, 2013
ConsMedium width
Bought these for my husband & he LOVES them! He says they are really comfy & they look good with everything! Love Allen Edmonds!!
Overall rating
5/ 5
runs small
runs large
runs narrow
runs wide
EnEf
fromSeattle
Age:25-29
Classic beauty
PostedJune 26, 2013
Prosclassic, well-made, gentlemanly
ConsMedium width
What can I say? These are sharp shoes. The walnut color is gorgeous. They will last forever, so pony up and get the best. Make sure to try them on. They run narrow and a bit large (about 1/2 size big), but they come in widths so there's sure to be one that fits you. Just don't say I didn't warn you if you order online and they don't fit to your satisfaction.
Overall rating
2/ 5
runs small
runs large
runs narrow
runs wide
JDouglas
fromeast coast
Age:50-54
Disappointed .... buyer beware!
PostedJune 21, 2013
The product description says:
"Vintage-style broguing details a handsomely crafted leather oxford with an antiqued double leather sole and McAfee heel."
I was looking forward to this shoe, but what I received was not the original Player shoes as described above. What I received was a "single oak" leather sole and the standard heel. I guess AE is no longer making the original version of this shoe for Nordstrom. If that is the case, the product description should be updated.
I have several pairs of AE shoes with double soles, like the MacNeil and the Walton that I purchased from Nordstrom. I really like the comfort and durability of this specific shoe construction.I am disappointed that the Player is not as advertised and will be sending this back to Nordstrom.
3 of 3 found this review helpful.
Overall rating
4/ 5
runs small
runs large
runs narrow
runs wide
SANJD
Age:25-29
Great shoe, try on first
PostedFebruary 8, 2013
Prosversatile, classic
ConsMedium width
One of the best looking AE shoes in my opinion, a classic wingtip in their fantastic Walnut color. This shoe is on their #2 last which is described as "Elongated toe with a slightly higher instep. Very similar to the 108 last." The one gripe I have about these shoes is that I feel the heel area is a bit too narrow for my foot. Heel slip was a bit of an issue at first, but has gotten much better with break in and the use of tongue pads for a more secure fit. The shoes have become much more comfortable after a short break in period and have become one of my favorite pairs to wear. They are extremely versatile and can be worn with a variety of clothing, allowing you to dress them up or down. I would definitely recommend trying them on first unless you are familiar with AE sizing and particularly this last.
