I purchased the No5 Vibrant Blue. Since it's Waterproof, I didn't expect it to smudge...but it did. It smudged under the bottom lashes, and since I have naturally long lashes it smudged in a few areas below the bottom lashes as well.
I like the shade a lot, but really expected more from YSL.
Overall rating
3/ 5
kismet44
fromMaryland
Skin Type:sensitive
Skin Tone:light
Eye Color:brown
Age:45-49
Disappointed, Bring back AquaResitant!!!
PostedJanuary 20, 2012
The only plus for me is the color. I adored the Aquaresistant YSL mascara and had high hopes for this. There is no comparison. This was thin coverage and no real curl for me.
Overall rating
5/ 5
PMD72
fromDearborn, MI
Skin Type:oily
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:black
Age:35-39
Finally found the one!
PostedAugust 29, 2011
Prosvolumizing, defining, long-wearing
As someone with very oily skin, I have been a mascara brand hopper for YEARS. The is the first I've tried in ages that I'm planning on purchasing again when it's time for a new tube.
The brush is unique and evenly distributes the mascara with no clumping. it provides great volume. And most importantly, stays put. I love it!
This mascara and the Rouge Pur Couture are great "brand ambassadors," I look forward to trying more in this line.
Overall rating
5/ 5
Rene2020
fromLivonia, MI
Skin Type:dry
Skin Tone:light
Eye Color:blue
Age:40-44
Excellent Mascara
PostedAugust 2, 2011
Prosdefining, lengthening, curling
I am new to the YSL Mascara line so I can't compare this to any other YSL mascara, but I purchased this in the teal blue/geen color for fun and I am in love with the formula. I always have to curl my lashes with an eye lash curler and once I apply mascara, the wetness of it basically straightens my lashes back out. They hardly have any bend to them. This is NOT true with the Singulier mascara. My lashes looked long, lush and held the curl all day until I soaked the mascara off with eye makeup remover. I am so impressed, I want to go back and get it in black. No other mascara in the whole cosmetics department has made my lashes look this awesome. I may just go return my clumpy DiorShow mascara today!!
