36 out of 39(92%)reviewers recommend this product.
Product Reviews
Overall rating
4/ 5
BridgeNTunnel
fromEmeryville
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:light
Eye Color:brown
Age:35-39
Does smear for hooded eyelids
PostedAugust 5, 2012
Proseasy to blend, smudgable, soft
I love the soft, smooth, non-tugging qualities and the brown color, which creates a beautiful smoky eye, but because I have hooded Asian eyelids, the color smudged and stain part of the eyelid, even though I let it dry before blinking. The Tarte SmolderEyes stays put better.
Overall rating
5/ 5
dpj80
fromMidwest
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:green
Age:55-59
Perfect Eyeliner!
PostedAugust 5, 2012
Proseasy to blend, smudgable, long-lasting
Love YSL waterproof eye pencils! Go on smooth and easy, colors are beautiful, and they stay put all day long! Had been looking for years for the perfect color, the perfect ease of application, and the perfect stay-put-all-day eyeliner and this is the one! I have green eyes and like the color burgundy best. Not too dark and not too light. I've thrown out all the other brands.
Overall rating
5/ 5
Queenie145
fromCamano Island, WA
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:medium
Eye Color:blue
Age:60-64
Beautiful Color
PostedJune 15, 2012
Proseasy to blend, smudgable, long-lasting
The Azure Blue is a beautiful color that really brings out the green in my blue/green eyes. Not too bright or artificial-looking, this blue shade is just right. It's long-wearing and very easy to apply, doesn't negatively affect my sensitive eyes, and has become my favorite eyeliner.
Overall rating
5/ 5
LizinRI
fromDenver
Skin Type:combination
Skin Tone:light
Eye Color:green
Age:20-24
Great Product
PostedMay 29, 2012
Proslong-lasting, vibrant, fashion forward
This eyeliner is wonderful! It's long-lasting, vibrant and easy to apply. For me, the color stays put for at least a whole work day (8 hours or so) without any noticeable fading. I bought the blue and the gold, and get tons of compliments when I wear either of them. I especially have to recommend the blue for summer, it's such a beautiful shade, and it really pops against any eye color. One of my favorite YSL products!
