LOVE!! When I tried them on in store, the location didn't have the tobacco color in stock so I tried the oil rubbed black leather. The were very tight, as I have wide feet, but I figured leather stretches. So I ordered them. When they came, they fit perfectly! No stretching needed. They look amazing, and feel great. 4 stars because the under strap near the toes has rubbed a small blister on my toe- but that's common with any leather shoe.
Fits great, color is very nice and comfortable according to my dad. He has tried Birkenstocks for men but it does not fit him well, either to big or wide for his feet. The same w/ my husband for this style of Birkenstock, I buy him the women's sandals.