The "top" sandal has just the right amount of cushion to be comfortable. They look cute and are a must have in black! Sizing: These were ordered for my daughter (size 9) and I tested them (size 10). Our feet are a little narrow as well. Based on other reviews, I ordered the larger size (41) but it was totally unnecessary. I re-ordered and got the size 39 which fit perfect for a regular size 9. Even for me (size 10), the 41's were a bit long/wide.